Yvonne L. reviewed on 11/21/2011 + 929 more book reviews

It was okay. Kind of glad I didnt spend money or a credit on it.

Surprisingly Jill Shlaviss All He Wants for Christmas was the worst one of the three. I got the book because I usually like her stuff. But I found the story lacking and the characters flat. Cristinas hesitancy was annoying and she was so slow on the uptake. I was kind of glad when Dustin finally ditched her and dont know why he would ever want her back.

I dont remember reading DAlessandro before but My Grown-Up Christmas List was cute. Its very similar to the first story but the characters were better developed.

Up on the Houstop was promising. Ive never heard of Jamie Sobrato and wonder if she was a new writer. She writes like someone who wasnt very experienced but it was still a fine story. The ending was really lame and some of the parts felts sparse but I enjoyed it.

For a series on firefighters based in the same town, I was disappointed there wasnt more of a connection between the three stories. At the same time the stories were too much alike that I was getting bored when I got to the third one.

Not a bad read for a library find but thats it.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details