Elizabeth B. (Cattriona) - reviewed on 3/9/2008 + 200 more book reviews

Helpful Score: 2

I was deeply disappointed in this. Though the story centered around Surreal, many of the usual characters made appearances -- Daemon, the High Lord, Jaenelle, Tersa, Marion, the kindred -- their involvement was fairly limited and superficial, despite the book's description implying that the entire family will come together to help one of their own. The plot itself seemed very shallow and contrived, with Surreal being tricked into arriving at this "Haunted House", then appearing to be fairly helpless within, which is out of character for Surreal. Jaenelle appeared particularly insipid and, in general, the story lacked credibility and was dreadfully predictable. I loved the original Blood trilogy, as well as the volume of short stories, and re-read them frequently, but this has no "re-read" value at all.

The one bright spot was a previously published short story about one of Surreal's assassination jobs which was included at the end. It was much more in the flavor of the original stories and very enjoyable, though short.

Great fans of the series will want to read this for a bit of background on Surreal and an update on Jaenelle and her Twilight's Dawn, but it is, unfortunately, not a "keeper". Those who are not fans of Bishop's series, don't bother.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details