Brenna B. (demiducky25) reviewed on 9/29/2008 + 161 more book reviews

Although I really enjoyed this book (not as good as the first, but liked it better than the second), I was annoyed by a few inconsistencies. I could have sworn that the author, in the first book, mentioned that the girls didn't attend the same school (except for Carmen and Lena maybe), but in this one she alludes to them attending the same graduation ceremony (if she meant they all went to watch one of the girls graduate, it wasn't made very clear). Also, the author mentioned in one of the other books how Carmen and her mother moved to the apartment when her father left in elementary school, but in this book she mentions having her nursery in that bedroom in the apartment when she was little. However, these few little things didn't take away from the book itself. The characters seem older now, perhaps not wiser in all things, but wiser in some things. Tibby's story continues to be my favorite and the character of Carmen is finally growing on me since this time she has a different story beyond getting used to dad's love life (1st book) and getting used to mom's love life (2nd book).

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details