Jill P. (booksaregrand) - , reviewed on 7/8/2010 + 75 more book reviews

Helpful Score: 3

So this is book 5 in the Malory series and I liked it. The villain was a little heinous, but it didn't bother me. Be forewarned though it may bother some people. I liked Derek's story. Kelsey wasn't my favorite heroine, but was still liked. I enjoyed reading more about Derek's father and seeing more of James. However I have to admit that this is the book I look at to mark the point I think the Malory novels started going downhill. I just don't enjoy 6, 7, 8 as much as books 1-5. The first 4 were amazing. All charcters wonderful and perfect in every way. There is just so much lacking in the later novels. I wonder if Lindsey is even writing some of her own books sometimes. I'm reading number 9 now and I am liking it so far and I have high hopes for book 10. All in all I recommend reading all the Malory novels as they are such a wonderful family and series, but after this book the books do start to go downhill.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details