Elizabeth B. (Cattriona) - reviewed on 4/7/2011 + 200 more book reviews

This book tries to be a cross between a scientific analysis of survival and stories of disasters, but succeeds at neither. Parts were written for publication elsewhere and it shows -- repetitive use of the same phrases ("spicy juniper smell" every time there's a mountain nearby), constant references to "Tao Te Ching" and a very disjointed rhythm with no real flow. The writing is choppy and lacking in scientific support, with accident accounts frequently interrupted by the author pontificating on some spiritual observation. The author name-drops frequently, and takes great pains to be sure we know he's done all sorts of cool, manly stuff, none of which teaches us much about surviving accidents. This is best illustrated in the index, where the longest listing is not of references to hypothermia or risk management, but for the personal exploits of the author. Skip this pointless, ego-puffing narrative and read Amanda Ripley's "The Unthinkable" to actually learn something about survival. Not recommended.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details