Helpful Score: 3
~ A pleasurable read with wonderful leading characters - though darker and more risque than I had expected! (3.5 stars) ~
TEMPTED ALL NIGHT is a very enjoyable read, though I was a little surprised by certain aspects of the book. There are some very dark undertones (sexual slavery) and some surprises that I wasn't quite expecting (bondage-domination ... which led to inconsistencies IMO - see spoilers for detail), however I have no compunction in recommending this book as a great historical romance read. (Note: I haven't read Carlyle's latest books that involve overlapping characters but this was not an obstacle).
There are a lot of things that could be included in the following descriptions but that I would have to term spoilers, so for people who want to avoid those, I have only detailed them at the very end (with a proper warning!!) for those readers who like to know some things beforehand (like me, lol).
CHARACTERS, Tristan and Phaedra ("Phae"):
Tristan Talbot (30) is a rake of the first order - he's a shameless flirt who literally beds every willing woman he meets. This wastrel devil-may-care facade, however, does hide a more serious side (still waters run deep type of thing) and Carlyle does a good job of writing this believably and making his feelings for and reaction to Phaedra read authentically. He's intelligent, witty, honorable, tender, passionate, sometimes deliciously possessive and jealous (his reaction at the card-game will have you grinning), and all in all completely sigh-inspiring - give me a Tristan any day!
Tristan is technically Lord Avoncliffe, since he's the son of the Earl of Hauxton, but he does not have a good relationship with his father and doesn't like to go by his title. His mother was of Mediterranean peasantry and though Hauxton married her, their marriage was not a happy one and ended in Tristan's youth. Though he's legitimate, one would almost think he wasn't by how he's treated by his extended family, his father, and society.
Lady Phaedra Northampton (21) is a great heroine - somewhat reserved but caring, intelligent, witty, likeable, and very easy to root for - all you want is for her to finally be happy. (I did find parts of her story/character very puzzling, but that's covered in the spoiler section at the end.) She's 21, though I found that I often had to remind myself that, since I felt she was written much older. I always love unusual heroines or the quiet-wallflowers, and Phaedra is this type - although 21 is hardly firmly on-the-shelf (even then!), she is the farthest thing from a social-butterfly, considers herself a bluestocking and unfashionable, hides behind plain gray gowns and spectacles, and is often wonderfully forthright and tart.
I felt that she was a good counterbalance to Tristan's wildness and their relationship was very believable; they have an intellectual and emotional/physical connection, are both wildly passionate and heartbreakingly tender with one another - it's really quite sweet (and I'm not the maudlin/corny type).
COMMENTS:
~ This book involves a mystery subplot - though action subplot would be more accurate, since there's not really the unknown-villain factor. On the whole it's written well, is interesting, and definitely moves the plot forward, but at the beginning of the book it takes too long for Carlyle to give us a picture of what is going on (that Missie is missing, Phaedra is looking for her, their connection to the first dead man, etc.).
~ The secondary characters are three-dimensional and well-written; not every relationship is tied up with a pretty bow at the end, and this gives a further feeling of authenticity to Carlyle's story and her hero and heroine's relationship.
~ A better proofreader was needed: there were typos, words missing or out of order, and consistency mistakes (at one point Tristan's title is raised to that of Earl Avoncliffe, before returning once more to Viscount).
~ I think that Tristan's proposal could have done with just the ring - leave the diamond and purple velvet handcuffs behind! That was too much for me, frankly ...
~ We don't know Phaedra's deep, dark secret for so long and maybe I'm just impatient, but I was annoyed by this; I kept on having to stop myself from skimming forward to find out what it was. Then, what the secret actually was didn't fit with other things in the story ... (see spoiler).
**BIG SPOILER STARTS**:
Phaedra's secret: Right after she turned 15, one of her brother's friends seduced her (ie. raped her, though that word is not used). She was so young that she didn't really understand what they were doing or that they were having sex (or what sex was). She gets pregnant as a result, though again she doesn't realize it or recognize what it means, and then is given an abortion (again, not really understanding what is happening). Something goes wrong, she gets a bad fever, and as a result is told she will likely never be able to conceive. She pretty much withdraws from society, thinking that since she's barren she will never marry.
Second issue: Now, I like the hot and heavy scenes as much as the next historical romance reader and am disappointed when there isn't enough chemistry or passion, but I guess I'm somewhat prudish in that I do prefer my heroines to not initially be too bold or sexually aggressive at the beginning of their relationship with the hero. Here, however, I was completely unprepared for the bondage/domination aspect of Tristan and Phaedra's relationship and haven't read this in any of Carlyle's books before. It was well-written, though, and I think it mostly just caught me off guard.
Having said that, if you're somewhat turned off by this, don't be - as I said, I'm not the really raunchy x-rated type of reader, but I was not disturbed by it - only pleasantly scandalized, lol. The thing that I did find somewhat disconcerting/odd was that both of these things (Phaedra's secret and this aspect of their sexual relationship) were taking place in the same book/relationship. After what she experienced, would Phae really so soon in her sexual relationship with Tristan (and in her first sexual experience since her rape) be comfortable with or desire/need to be bound/dominated? I found it hard to reconcile these two things, as I would find it more probable that Phaedra would be hesitant about sex because of what happened to her.
**BIG SPOILER ENDS**
(http://historical-romance-heaven.blogspot.com)
TEMPTED ALL NIGHT is a very enjoyable read, though I was a little surprised by certain aspects of the book. There are some very dark undertones (sexual slavery) and some surprises that I wasn't quite expecting (bondage-domination ... which led to inconsistencies IMO - see spoilers for detail), however I have no compunction in recommending this book as a great historical romance read. (Note: I haven't read Carlyle's latest books that involve overlapping characters but this was not an obstacle).
There are a lot of things that could be included in the following descriptions but that I would have to term spoilers, so for people who want to avoid those, I have only detailed them at the very end (with a proper warning!!) for those readers who like to know some things beforehand (like me, lol).
CHARACTERS, Tristan and Phaedra ("Phae"):
Tristan Talbot (30) is a rake of the first order - he's a shameless flirt who literally beds every willing woman he meets. This wastrel devil-may-care facade, however, does hide a more serious side (still waters run deep type of thing) and Carlyle does a good job of writing this believably and making his feelings for and reaction to Phaedra read authentically. He's intelligent, witty, honorable, tender, passionate, sometimes deliciously possessive and jealous (his reaction at the card-game will have you grinning), and all in all completely sigh-inspiring - give me a Tristan any day!
Tristan is technically Lord Avoncliffe, since he's the son of the Earl of Hauxton, but he does not have a good relationship with his father and doesn't like to go by his title. His mother was of Mediterranean peasantry and though Hauxton married her, their marriage was not a happy one and ended in Tristan's youth. Though he's legitimate, one would almost think he wasn't by how he's treated by his extended family, his father, and society.
Lady Phaedra Northampton (21) is a great heroine - somewhat reserved but caring, intelligent, witty, likeable, and very easy to root for - all you want is for her to finally be happy. (I did find parts of her story/character very puzzling, but that's covered in the spoiler section at the end.) She's 21, though I found that I often had to remind myself that, since I felt she was written much older. I always love unusual heroines or the quiet-wallflowers, and Phaedra is this type - although 21 is hardly firmly on-the-shelf (even then!), she is the farthest thing from a social-butterfly, considers herself a bluestocking and unfashionable, hides behind plain gray gowns and spectacles, and is often wonderfully forthright and tart.
I felt that she was a good counterbalance to Tristan's wildness and their relationship was very believable; they have an intellectual and emotional/physical connection, are both wildly passionate and heartbreakingly tender with one another - it's really quite sweet (and I'm not the maudlin/corny type).
COMMENTS:
~ This book involves a mystery subplot - though action subplot would be more accurate, since there's not really the unknown-villain factor. On the whole it's written well, is interesting, and definitely moves the plot forward, but at the beginning of the book it takes too long for Carlyle to give us a picture of what is going on (that Missie is missing, Phaedra is looking for her, their connection to the first dead man, etc.).
~ The secondary characters are three-dimensional and well-written; not every relationship is tied up with a pretty bow at the end, and this gives a further feeling of authenticity to Carlyle's story and her hero and heroine's relationship.
~ A better proofreader was needed: there were typos, words missing or out of order, and consistency mistakes (at one point Tristan's title is raised to that of Earl Avoncliffe, before returning once more to Viscount).
~ I think that Tristan's proposal could have done with just the ring - leave the diamond and purple velvet handcuffs behind! That was too much for me, frankly ...
~ We don't know Phaedra's deep, dark secret for so long and maybe I'm just impatient, but I was annoyed by this; I kept on having to stop myself from skimming forward to find out what it was. Then, what the secret actually was didn't fit with other things in the story ... (see spoiler).
**BIG SPOILER STARTS**:
Phaedra's secret: Right after she turned 15, one of her brother's friends seduced her (ie. raped her, though that word is not used). She was so young that she didn't really understand what they were doing or that they were having sex (or what sex was). She gets pregnant as a result, though again she doesn't realize it or recognize what it means, and then is given an abortion (again, not really understanding what is happening). Something goes wrong, she gets a bad fever, and as a result is told she will likely never be able to conceive. She pretty much withdraws from society, thinking that since she's barren she will never marry.
Second issue: Now, I like the hot and heavy scenes as much as the next historical romance reader and am disappointed when there isn't enough chemistry or passion, but I guess I'm somewhat prudish in that I do prefer my heroines to not initially be too bold or sexually aggressive at the beginning of their relationship with the hero. Here, however, I was completely unprepared for the bondage/domination aspect of Tristan and Phaedra's relationship and haven't read this in any of Carlyle's books before. It was well-written, though, and I think it mostly just caught me off guard.
Having said that, if you're somewhat turned off by this, don't be - as I said, I'm not the really raunchy x-rated type of reader, but I was not disturbed by it - only pleasantly scandalized, lol. The thing that I did find somewhat disconcerting/odd was that both of these things (Phaedra's secret and this aspect of their sexual relationship) were taking place in the same book/relationship. After what she experienced, would Phae really so soon in her sexual relationship with Tristan (and in her first sexual experience since her rape) be comfortable with or desire/need to be bound/dominated? I found it hard to reconcile these two things, as I would find it more probable that Phaedra would be hesitant about sex because of what happened to her.
**BIG SPOILER ENDS**
(http://historical-romance-heaven.blogspot.com)
Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
