Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Review of The Box Garden

The Box Garden
The Box Garden
Author: Carol Shields
Genre: Literature & Fiction
Book Type: Paperback
Rebemdee avatar reviewed on
Helpful Score: 2


I enjoyed the book. I think it has a "mature chick lit" theme. I do find the comments in the Amazon.com review, about how now Charleen would be given Prozac and sent on her way, both insulting and untrue. It is insulting from the standpoint that most competent doctors do not believe medication treats social issues and existential angst. I find it untrue in that Charleen does not appear depressed or anxious; she seems to be redefining herself after her life has been turned upside down, and it takes going back to where she started to find out how far she has come, and how strong and independent she is now. The twists and turns weren't hard to figure out, but didn't seem forced or contrived. I enjoyed the novel. It isn't ritzy or racy, but a wonderful story of growth and acceptance.