This book's author is Dick King-Smith, who wrote "Babe, the Gallant Pig" on which the movie "Babe" was based. Supposedly it is a children's book (ages 7-10), but I disagree with that. PBS does too, as it is not listed for these ages on the book's page.
The book's pretended aim is to encourage children how to read. I think the author really uses it to vent his interests in child violence, racism, sexism and casual sex.
Flora, the main character, is a young female mouse from a litter of 10. Her nine brothers and sisters are either poisoned, or killed and eaten by foxes, owls or weasels. While the author doesn't describe their deaths in detail, their deaths might traumatize young readers. Her mother's next litter of nine doesn't last long either. In fact, Flora, when seeing one of her brothers eating poison, doesn't even bother to warn him or even call 911. What does such callowness teach a child?
Flora's father is often depicted as an air-head. What will this teach young children about their fathers?
When Flora first sees Buck, an escaped pet mouse, she describes him as being a "ghastly, ghostly, white," instead of the better "grey brown" of her own race, As such, she exhibits racism. Yet they eventually become lovers without befit of clergy. By the end of the book Flora becomes pregnant. These are yet other inappropriate lessons for young readers.
However, I ached for Flora when Buck severely beats her father, leaving him permanently lamed. But then they all pass it off as a minor incident. Are we now teaching children that violence against others is to be tolerated?
This are the reasons I only gave it one star.
So I won't be posting my copy here. I'll dispose of it in another way, at the Small Free Library at the state park where I volunteer. But, as of today, there are 19 other copies posted on PBS.
(Hey, if you can't have occasional fun with a review...... )
The book's pretended aim is to encourage children how to read. I think the author really uses it to vent his interests in child violence, racism, sexism and casual sex.
Flora, the main character, is a young female mouse from a litter of 10. Her nine brothers and sisters are either poisoned, or killed and eaten by foxes, owls or weasels. While the author doesn't describe their deaths in detail, their deaths might traumatize young readers. Her mother's next litter of nine doesn't last long either. In fact, Flora, when seeing one of her brothers eating poison, doesn't even bother to warn him or even call 911. What does such callowness teach a child?
Flora's father is often depicted as an air-head. What will this teach young children about their fathers?
When Flora first sees Buck, an escaped pet mouse, she describes him as being a "ghastly, ghostly, white," instead of the better "grey brown" of her own race, As such, she exhibits racism. Yet they eventually become lovers without befit of clergy. By the end of the book Flora becomes pregnant. These are yet other inappropriate lessons for young readers.
However, I ached for Flora when Buck severely beats her father, leaving him permanently lamed. But then they all pass it off as a minor incident. Are we now teaching children that violence against others is to be tolerated?
This are the reasons I only gave it one star.
So I won't be posting my copy here. I'll dispose of it in another way, at the Small Free Library at the state park where I volunteer. But, as of today, there are 19 other copies posted on PBS.
(Hey, if you can't have occasional fun with a review...... )
Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
