Tracy M. (tracymar) reviewed on 8/8/2009 + 408 more book reviews

The two related films, Jean de Florette and Manon of the Springs, have enthralled me since I first saw them. What a heartfelt tale, and a true Greek tragedy, although set in rural France of the early 20th century. Finally after watching the films for the third time, I decided that I had to read the book, and it was not a disappointment. The characters and rural environment come to life, adding more dimensions to the four hours of the film. This is a rare situation in which I suggest seeing the films first -- because some of the scenes in it are so powerfully and beautifully done. Reading the book(s) afterwards, you will more clearly visualize the scenes, and will be able to fill in any gaps in your understanding. The films are very true to the novels although they lack all the peripheral characters. The only discrepancy that comes to mind is that Manon and the schoolteacher seemed to forge more of a bond initially in the Manon of the Spring film than they did in the novel.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details