Lauren S. reviewed on
The only fiction I normally ever (and very rarely) read is that which is the most highly esteemed classic literature of the English language. Therefore, I was not at all impressed by the actual writing (grammar, language, style, construction, etc.) of this story. My standards are far too high.
I did enjoy the story overall. The characters became real enough to me that I could share their emotions somewhat--more of the pain than the joys.
The Christian gospel message was not direct/overt enough for my liking, nor was true Biblical doctrine clear enough. Confusion concerning Roman Catholicism is a huge concern-- an unbeliever reading this might wrongly conclude from this book that it is a valid form of Biblically orthodox Christianity.
I did not feel like the dialogue nor the relationships between the women of successive generations were realistic. Intensely emotional, life-transforming conversations seemed to happen far too quickly and be too short, but books can't always be 1000 pages long.
I think it's purpose was to promote extending grace and compassion, especially amongst family members, which is wonderful, but the intensity of the gospel message leading to definite salvation in Christ was lacking. I was left feeling unsure of the conversions of Emma and Suzanne, for example.
So this book was entertaining but I cannot recommend it very highly.
I did enjoy the story overall. The characters became real enough to me that I could share their emotions somewhat--more of the pain than the joys.
The Christian gospel message was not direct/overt enough for my liking, nor was true Biblical doctrine clear enough. Confusion concerning Roman Catholicism is a huge concern-- an unbeliever reading this might wrongly conclude from this book that it is a valid form of Biblically orthodox Christianity.
I did not feel like the dialogue nor the relationships between the women of successive generations were realistic. Intensely emotional, life-transforming conversations seemed to happen far too quickly and be too short, but books can't always be 1000 pages long.
I think it's purpose was to promote extending grace and compassion, especially amongst family members, which is wonderful, but the intensity of the gospel message leading to definite salvation in Christ was lacking. I was left feeling unsure of the conversions of Emma and Suzanne, for example.
So this book was entertaining but I cannot recommend it very highly.
Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
