Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Review of One True Loves

One True Loves
23dollars avatar reviewed on + 432 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1


ONE TRUE LOVES has a dynamite premise: What would happen if your husband died and you fell in love again after a couple of years and planned to remarry someone else, just to learn that your husband has been found alive after having only been lost at sea?

While I enjoyed the author's exploration of the emotional conflict, I think I would've enjoyed it more in the hands of an older, more mature writer. Emma, Jesse and Sam were in their 30s, but the substance of their relationships was very YA and juvenile. It felt shallow overall, with many depths going unexplored. This felt like a triangle of college freshmen vs. a triangle of grown adults.

The three MCs were all inherently good and noble people, which is nice, but it doesn't make for deeper exploration of human conflict and behavior, which a situation like this begs to explore. The figuring out ended up being a little too safe, too "clean."

Having said that, I did find ONE TRUE LOVES to be a worthwhile read, I enjoy the authenticity the author seems to strive for in her writing, but I would more readily recommend the author's other novel, AFTER I DO, over this one. I felt the telling of that story was better aligned with the characters' stage of development. 3.25 stars.