Suzanne S. (NWJumble) reviewed on
I loved Boyd's Any Human Heart, enjoyed An Ice-Cream War (after a slightly slower start), and looked forward to savoring Brazzaville Beach - which fell into the "enjoyable enough" category, but didn't quite live up to the reputation Boyd had established with me!
The First person-Third Person back and forth narrative was a tad contrived in its execution; unfortunately, neither the prologue that warned the reader this was upcoming, nor the context of the story as it unfolds, failed to justify this somewhat disjointed flip-flopping of time and narrative voice. Ultimately, it didn't bother me too much in the reading - in fact, I did become engaged in the parallel story of the emotional rise and fall of Hope Clearwater's once-brilliant, mathemetician husband. And, if I felt like expending the energy to think literarily, I'm sure interesting analogies could be drawn between the England-side story and the AFrica-chimpanzee story (but unfortunately Boyd's crafting doesn't inspire that effort as well as I suspect he could have).
But I read good fiction, in all honesty, to be moved, absorbed or - yes - entertained, at some level. The "fine writing" or "literary cleverness" part can't interfere with my being grabbed. I realize Boyd failed, for me, in most part because I never believed in Hope as a credible female character. She was neither a real human woman, nor a fantasy super-female heroine, but lay nebulously somewhere in between. The only vividly real and intriguing character was Hope's husband. I'm left to conclude that Boyd just doesn't show his best with female protagonists, and fortunately, he went on to write more compellingly about men in the afore-mentioned novels.
Nevertheless, I am glad I read Brazzaville Beach - it is entertaining and interesting enough - I'm merely judging the author by his later work. Anyone who wants to round out their 'Boyd experience' would enjoy adding this to the mix! If it's the first book you read, be sure not to miss Any Human Heart!
The First person-Third Person back and forth narrative was a tad contrived in its execution; unfortunately, neither the prologue that warned the reader this was upcoming, nor the context of the story as it unfolds, failed to justify this somewhat disjointed flip-flopping of time and narrative voice. Ultimately, it didn't bother me too much in the reading - in fact, I did become engaged in the parallel story of the emotional rise and fall of Hope Clearwater's once-brilliant, mathemetician husband. And, if I felt like expending the energy to think literarily, I'm sure interesting analogies could be drawn between the England-side story and the AFrica-chimpanzee story (but unfortunately Boyd's crafting doesn't inspire that effort as well as I suspect he could have).
But I read good fiction, in all honesty, to be moved, absorbed or - yes - entertained, at some level. The "fine writing" or "literary cleverness" part can't interfere with my being grabbed. I realize Boyd failed, for me, in most part because I never believed in Hope as a credible female character. She was neither a real human woman, nor a fantasy super-female heroine, but lay nebulously somewhere in between. The only vividly real and intriguing character was Hope's husband. I'm left to conclude that Boyd just doesn't show his best with female protagonists, and fortunately, he went on to write more compellingly about men in the afore-mentioned novels.
Nevertheless, I am glad I read Brazzaville Beach - it is entertaining and interesting enough - I'm merely judging the author by his later work. Anyone who wants to round out their 'Boyd experience' would enjoy adding this to the mix! If it's the first book you read, be sure not to miss Any Human Heart!
Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
