Althea M. (althea) reviewed on 2/18/2009 + 774 more book reviews

Helpful Score: 2

Although I love nearly all of Connie Willis' books, I hadn't been that impressed by the other two I've read which she wrote in collaboration with Cynthia Felice: "Light Raid," which was entertaining enough, but not exceptional, and "Water Witch," which was too much of a romance novel for my taste. "Promised Land" is also a romance novel. I got the impression that it might even have originally been conceived of as a Wild West kinda romance, and then the authors decided to put a sci-fi veneer over the story. Delanna is a city girl who's been at school off-planet. But when her mother dies, she comes back to her frontier planet to liquidate her mother's farm and collect her inheritance. She barely recognizes the hayseed hick who comes to meet her, whom she knew as a little girl, but she takes an instant dislike to him. It's a complete shock to her to discover, that under planetary laws designed to protect family homesteads, she's married to him, and is legally unable to sell her land unless she lives on it - with him - for a year. She has no other assets, so she's forced to travel out to the land, which is literally in the middle of nowhere.
of course, a couple of other guys have romantic designs on Delanna, and there's a few light subplots here and there, but mainly Delanna becomes guilty that her mother always sent her money that she spent on parties and fancy clothes, learns to value the fruit of her own labors, falls in love with the hick, comes to appreciate the Simple Life, and decides to stay on the farm. Ugh, ugh, ugh. Puh-leeze.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details