Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Review of Speaks the Nightbird (Matthew Corbett, Bk 1)

Speaks the Nightbird (Matthew Corbett, Bk 1)
hro avatar reviewed on
Helpful Score: 2


The Carolinas, 1699. The newly founded town of Fount Royal is facing a rash of disasters - murders, arsons, failed crops, illness. In desperation, the citizens cast the blame on Rachel Howarth and accuse her of witchcraft. Magistrate Isaac Woodward and his clerk Matthew Corbett arrive to preside over the trial and to determine Rachels fate. But Matthew soon realizes there is something far more sinister than witchcraft going on in Fount Royal. He risks everything to solve the mystery.and to exonerate Rachel.

The writing quality of Speaks the Nightbird is good; in fact, it is a notch above what I would expect to find in a mainstream genre fiction book. Other than that, all the things I liked were tempered with things I disliked.

The characters are rich and well developed, with distinctive personalities and solid back stories. However, almost everyone is completely unhinged. Insanity, in one form or another, runs rampant in this book, to the point of being unbelievable.

There are extensive descriptions of everything - clothing, cuisine, weather, landscape, furniture, tools, etc. While this made for a very visual read, it grew quite tiresome, and it somehow failed to add a sense of time to the story. And there was an unnecessary amount of vulgarity and crudity, which bothered me and added to my feeling that this was a more modern story. I rarely felt that I was reading about 1699.

The plot twists become increasingly outlandish as the book progresses. And when the mystery is solved and the motive and method revealed, I was stupefied at how ludicrous it was. Pirate treasure and hypnotism? Are you kidding? I read 900+ pages for that ridiculous conclusion? I feel so cheated.