Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Martha P. (MartyP) - Reviews

1 to 11 of 11
Born on a Mountaintop: On the Road with Davy Crockett and the Ghosts of the Wild Frontier
Review Date: 2/17/2015


I really enjoyed this book. It's readable, it's fun, and the author doesn't take sides in the various Crockett controversies, but rather, treats all of them with respect and leaves the reader to decide for him/herself where the historical truth lies. Highly recommended for anyone who grew up during the Disney craze, or who has visited the Alamo, or who just wants to delve into this facet of Americana.


Byzantium
Byzantium
Author: Stephen R. Lawhead
Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
  • Currently 4.1/5 Stars.
 68
Review Date: 9/22/2010
Helpful Score: 2


I really enjoyed this book. It's good historical fiction; its hero is an Irish monk who ends up a slave of the Vikings and then in the Holy Roman Emperor's court in Constantinople. There's enough action and misadventure and plot twists to keep the reader entertained, and it really reads quite quickly. I did wish that the book included an introduction to help put the story into historical context -- I had to do a little research to remind myself why Constantinople was the "new Rome" in pre-Crusades Middle Ages -- but that's why we have google, I guess.


City Room
City Room
Author: Arthur Gelb
Book Type: Paperback
  • Currently 4/5 Stars.
 1
Review Date: 6/28/2014


Definitely a "must" for anyone who enjoys The New York Times and/or New York City. It may be sacrilege to suggest, but I did think Arthur Gelb could have used a good editor -- the book could have been 100 pages shorter and just that much tighter. Having said that, it was great to hear Gelb's anecdotes about well-known "bylines" at the times, as well as his insider's account of all the stories the Times broke during his four decades on the paper.


Darcy's Story
Darcy's Story
Author: Janet Aylmer
Book Type: Paperback
  • Currently 3.2/5 Stars.
 193
Review Date: 2/23/2010
Helpful Score: 1


I'm a Janeite who likes my Austen un-retouched. I don't need modern authors to create new adventures for Austen heroines, thank you very much. I selected Darcy's Story precisely because several of the reviewers complained that they didn't learn anything new from the book. That's precisely the point.

Darcy's Story does NOT change the story, and only creates a few new scenes. What it does is offer a new point-of-view from which to consider the actions of the Austen characters. I must admit that I, who thought I knew P&P backwards and forwards, learned new details from reading this book.

Darcy's Story suffers in that the conversations added by Aylmer use entirely different language -- much simpler words, much less thoughtful speech -- than those conversations taken from the original. But perhaps Aylmer did this on purpose -- it is, after all, very obvious which words are Austen's and which are hers, even to readers who do not know P&P almost verbatim.


George Washington's Secret Six: The Spy Ring that Saved the American Revolution
Review Date: 8/27/2018


Footnotes would be useful in a book that claims to explore "new" history, and it should be noted that the bibliography at the end is mostly secondary source material. Which makes me wonder how much of the story is the authors' imaginations run wild?


Michelangelo and the Pope's Ceiling
Michelangelo and the Pope's Ceiling
Author: Ross King
Book Type: Paperback
  • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
 74
Review Date: 2/23/2010


A fabulous popular history. I had studied the Sistine ceiling in art history class -- who hasn't? but I had never had a chance to learn of the political struggles engulfing Italy or the personal problems besetting Michelangelo during its creation. All in all, a great read.


An Odyssey: A Father, A Son, and an Epic
An Odyssey: A Father, A Son, and an Epic
Author: Daniel Mendelsohn
Book Type: Paperback
  • Currently 4/5 Stars.
 3
Review Date: 10/28/2020
Helpful Score: 1


I rarely write reviews, but this book is something special. It's the story of how a son comes to understand his father, as together they study the "Odyssey" and then share a trip to Greece. Incidents in the father-son relationship reimagine the epic poem; I suspect that's because the poem speaks to universal truths rather than anything unique in this particular father-son relationship. The book also offers incredibly insightful critique of the Homeric poem - I wish Mendelsohn had taught the course I took on Homer in college.


Pride and Prejudice and Mistletoe
Pride and Prejudice and Mistletoe
Author: Melissa de la Cruz
Book Type: Paperback
  • Currently 2.3/5 Stars.
 2
Review Date: 5/10/2021


Don't waste your time.
The protagonist's name - Darcy Fitzwilliam - is the only clever thing in the book. She's an unlikeable woman who constantly misbehaves at her parents' parties by drinking too much, but then, none of the characters have any resemblance to Jane Austin's. As far as I can tell, it's a breezily written romance novel with names of characters "borrowed" from the master.
Maybe I missed something amazing toward the end - I will admit I gave up around half-way through the book.


She Caused a Riot: 100 Unknown Women Who Built Cities, Sparked Revolutions, and Massively Crushed It
Review Date: 5/16/2020


Great idea for a book, but remarkably bad scholarship - the bibliography includes the Encyclopedia Brittanica as the only source for a number of chapters. Plus, the author constantly uses modern references to describe past cultures. The result is a mish-mash of commentary that may be funny - I guess that's a personal reflection - but certainly isn't informative. I quit at page 49.


Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare
Will in the World: How Shakespeare Became Shakespeare
Author: Stephen Greenblatt
Book Type: Hardcover
  • Currently 3.9/5 Stars.
 18
Review Date: 3/15/2010


This book compares Shakespeare's plays with what was happening to him personally and in the world politically at the time he was writing. It gets a bit fanciful -- but them I find all literary criticism a bit fanciful. It is an easy historical read, and added to my enjoyment of his work.


Year of Wonders
Year of Wonders
Author: Geraldine Brooks
Book Type: Paperback
  • Currently 3.7/5 Stars.
 9
Review Date: 9/13/2010
Helpful Score: 1


Can a novel set in the time of the plague be uplifting? I loved this book, and I loved the protagonist, a young woman trying to make sense of something beyond comprehension. The ending is a bit fantastic, but the entire book is a wonderful tour-de-force.


1 to 11 of 11