Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of Why We Broke Up

Why We Broke Up
Why We Broke Up
Author: Daniel Handler
ISBN-13: 9780316127257
ISBN-10: 0316127256
Publication Date: 1/2/2012
Pages: 368
Reading Level: Young Adult
Rating:
  • Currently 3.2/5 Stars.
 17

3.2 stars, based on 17 ratings
Publisher: Little, Brown Books for Young Readers
Book Type: Hardcover
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

2 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

reviewed Why We Broke Up on + 380 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Why we broke up
Summary:
This book is a long letter from Min explaining to Ed why the two of them broke up. It comes with a box that is filled with all of these random items from their relationship and Min goes through the memory that comes with each piece. Through this, we learn about Ed and Min's relationship. We learn about the rip of a poster that ended up with a first date, some bottle caps, a book of matches, and books that Min has kept as mementos of the relationship. Everything is accounted for while Min purges her memories onto the page of her letter to Ed. I'll give you a brief summary of the torn poster story, but honestly, this is a book where everything chains together to have the reader infer and use their own judgment more than pointing out every single thing that happened. Anyways, Min is helping her best friend Al hang posters advertising for Halloween events. She promised him, so she needed to make sure she lived up to her responsibilities even though her head is filled with puppy love la-la. While she is hanging posters, Ed comes over to her to talk for a few moments. When he needs to give her his phone number, he rips a piece of the poster that had just been hung and writes on it. At the time, Min doesn't think much about it, but after the breakup she notices that it was something she should have cared about because her friend had spent a lot of time on the posters. It was just one of a ton of things that showed how different Ed and Min were from one another.
My thoughts:
I really enjoyed this book. I thought it was fun and different. I was able to learn about the plot and the characters in a new way, and the little props were adorable. Ed was not a unlikeable character and Min never makes him out to be a horrible guy. He just has different priorities than Min has, and I think Min realizes that as she goes through each story. Min is not your normal teenager. She has a niche that she is really into, old movies, and she goes on tangents from time to time about that interest. I really enjoyed that, but I'm not sure it will keep the interest of my high school students. I'd just hope that the interactions between the characters would keep them interested in spite of the diatribes.
Since we come into the book already knowing that they broke up, I did not expect to like Ed at all. I assumed that it would end up being a broken hearted ex-girlfriend rant, like the ones where the girlfriend tares everything to pieces and throws everything around. Min is tossing the box at his front door, but she is actually pretty balanced between showing that Ed should be sad about things more than calling him a jerk. I was pleasantly surprised with every aspect of the book, and would love to recommend it to more people to read.
reviewed Why We Broke Up on + 23 more book reviews
First off, I was not aware this was a young adult book when I got it. I'm glad that I didn't know, because I wouldn't have read it if I had as that's just not normally what a woman in her mid 30s would enjoy. But it was a really fun book! It took me back to my high school days, and all the intensity of first loves and cliques and all the rest. I wish we could have gotten to know Ed better, but that's kind of the appeal of the book. It's true to life in that you never really know what another person is thinking. The first-person narrative was not nearly as annoying as I feared either. A light and fun read!