Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of When We Were Orphans (Audio CD) (Unabridged)

When We Were Orphans (Audio CD) (Unabridged)
When We Were Orphans - Audio CD - Unabridged
Author: Kazuo Ishiguro, John Lee (Narrator)
Audio Books swap for two (2) credits.
ISBN-13: 9780060824891
ISBN-10: 0060824891
Publication Date: 4/1/2005
Edition: Unabridged
Rating:
  • Currently 2.7/5 Stars.
 3

2.7 stars, based on 3 ratings
Publisher: HarperAudio
Book Type: Audio CD
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

2 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

reviewed When We Were Orphans (Audio CD) (Unabridged) on + 10 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Intense story. Against the backdrop of pending war, an orphaned detective returns to Shanghai from England to try to find his parents. Sometimes, we can get so involved in our quest that we lose contact with common sense.
miss-info avatar reviewed When We Were Orphans (Audio CD) (Unabridged) on + 386 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
This is the most nonsensical book I've read in years. While the writing style is mature, the plot could have been laid out by a ten-year-old, or perhaps someone influenced by the opium mentioned in the book. The narration continually referred to events that were not described in the book, then things go on as though we understand what's happening. Banks is supposed to be this world-famous detective, but we never actually witness him doing anything remotely intelligent. The only detective act we see him doing involves finding a house he thinks his parents were held in 20 years ago - and he believes that both his parents are still sitting in this house, waiting to be rescued. Who kidnaps adults, puts them in a house, then feeds them for 20 years? He's ready to storm this house with only a severely wounded soldier by his side, even though the soldier can't stand up without help. Finally someone says, "Well, you've been working on this case long enough, I'll just tell you what happened. You don't have to find it out for yourself after all." We're led to believe that his parents are so important that everyone - ambassadors, Chinese police, polititians - will drop everything to help him solve the case, and once the parents are found, it will help end the war. Why? His dad was a businessman, not a diplomat. I kept waiting for everything to tie together at the end, and it doesn't. No explanation why a guy he hardly knows from school brought him to his old house, why the guys who own the house will simply hand it over to him, or what happens to the house after all. No explanation why his mother didn't simply go to the British consolate and ask for safe passage home. (That would have solved the entire book.) No sequence of events between finding the truth (if it was the truth) and finding his mother. Just isolated events happening for no reason and with no logic, until things simply end.