This book earns a three star rating because it is Catherine Ryan Hyde and her writing alone deserves such. The story is about reincarnation, but even if I can let my mind go there and believe the premise, how it plays out is just too unbelievable. I do not believe that the main characters would be affected or act the way that they did. Sorry, but a love story between a 60 yr. old and 21 yr. old just stretches the imagination a bit too far.