Helpful Score: 2
Trains and Lovers: A Novel, by Alexander McCall Smith, was a surprise for me--and not in a good way. I'm a fan of Smith's other novels so I had a lot of hope for this book, especially from the description on the back of the book. I tried to read it but soon found myself skipping parts that were boring, getting confused about all the different characters that popped up, unable to follow the story as characters had flashbacks during flashbacks, etc. I finally just putting the book aside for good. I hate not to finish a book, especially by a really good author--I hang in there as long as I can, hoping it will redeem itself--but I couldn't do that with Trains and Lovers. There are too many books on my 'To Be Read' list for me to waste time with this one.
Helpful Score: 2
I have never read McCall Smith before. Strangers on a train,recounting their different experiences with love. Traveling from Edinburgh to London, a group of four strangers, three men one woman, manage to get close enough that they feel comfortable exchanging confidences. If you can keep your pessimistic nature in check, you will be treated to a smooth read, if not sleepy litany.
WELL WRITTEN, FAST MOVING,RIVETING STORIES
An enjoyable read, especially for romantics. I found it a bit difficult to keep track of the numerous characters but perhaps that's because I read this just before going to sleep. Interesting that four strangers would share somewhat intimate stories of their loves. Mr. Smith is an excellent storyteller. Reading this book makes me want to read others he has written.
