Dolores F. (txdee) reviewed The Surgeon's Lady (Harlequin Historical, No 949) on + 17 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 3
This is a story about the slowly developing love between two seemingly mismatched people meeting and learning about each other and themselves under difficult circumstances. She is a widow who failed to give her older husband an heir; he is a surgeon in the Royal Navy who rose above his "common" roots to educate himself. The setting is the Napoleonic war and is a sequel to Kelly's previous book, "Marrying the Captain". In fact, a couple from that book figure in this book as well so we get to see their ongoing story. Carla Kelly always focuses on character development rather than contrived plots. Her romance is subtle but satisfying. You will like the heroine and sigh over the hero who is truly a good man and perfect for her.
Carol S. (anicky) reviewed The Surgeon's Lady (Harlequin Historical, No 949) on + 55 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
This is the second book in a series of regency books featuring the Royal navy. The books are well written and historically correct. It is refreshing to find a novel where the main concern isn't that the leading lady marry a Lord. These stories feature the middle class at the time. A clever twist.
Helpful Score: 1
A little slow moving but still a wonderful, sweet romance.
Regina (virgosun) reviewed The Surgeon's Lady (Harlequin Historical, No 949) on + 888 more book reviews
This story has the sensual heat of a Barbara Cartland novel (barely there) but what it does have is strong character development and a sweet, satisfying plot. I don't think I've ever read a tale detailing such a vivid medical viewpoint and the deep sacrifices the military men and their families were forced to make. I was fascinated, but I missed the physical romance. Even so, The Surgeon's Lady is worth reading, but I give it only 3.2 stars because I prefer that physical love is balanced with an otherwise strong romance.
One of the things I most enjoy is the fact that Carla Kelly's stories are character driven; they are ordinary folks doing extraordinary things. British surgeon, Lt. Philemon Brittle, is doing his part during the Napoleon War. The author is as much a historian as a novelist; some of the scenes are extremely realistic and graphic.
This is the second book in a trilogy about the British Navy. Philemon Brittle is a warm, caring and funny man; while Lady Laura Taunton begins as a tragic figure. Essentially, Laura is a widow who was sold (by her father) to an older lord via marriage. Laura spent several years trying to beget an heir for her husband's line to no avail. Laura is traumatized in her relationships with men; she seems bowed by her experiences. However, we soon learn that Laura has a core of steel.
Another one of the things I enjoy about this author's books is the fact that she does not explain to us what she is doing; she does it and assumes we are intelligent enough to understand. I appreciate that. Love develops between Philemon and Laura gradually, as they work together to heal the men who have been injured while fighting Napoleon. Laura also begins to heal through her interactions with Philemon, the wounded and even the autocratic head of the hospital.
This is a well-written story, well worth a reader's time.
Channel Fleet
1. Marrying the Captain (2008)
2. The Surgeon's Lady (2009)
3. Marrying the Royal Marine (2010)
This is the second book in a trilogy about the British Navy. Philemon Brittle is a warm, caring and funny man; while Lady Laura Taunton begins as a tragic figure. Essentially, Laura is a widow who was sold (by her father) to an older lord via marriage. Laura spent several years trying to beget an heir for her husband's line to no avail. Laura is traumatized in her relationships with men; she seems bowed by her experiences. However, we soon learn that Laura has a core of steel.
Another one of the things I enjoy about this author's books is the fact that she does not explain to us what she is doing; she does it and assumes we are intelligent enough to understand. I appreciate that. Love develops between Philemon and Laura gradually, as they work together to heal the men who have been injured while fighting Napoleon. Laura also begins to heal through her interactions with Philemon, the wounded and even the autocratic head of the hospital.
This is a well-written story, well worth a reader's time.
Channel Fleet
1. Marrying the Captain (2008)
2. The Surgeon's Lady (2009)
3. Marrying the Royal Marine (2010)
