Cathy C. (cathyskye) -
Helpful Score: 3
Catherine Bailey kept me glued to the page throughout two-thirds of this book. When she first entered the Muniment Rooms of Belvoir Castle, I was flabbergasted as she began telling of all the historical documents the ninth duke had amassed, and how he had organized and cataloged them. The discovery of the three missing periods during his life led to a fascinating recounting of how she managed to fill in the blanks. Touted as a book for fans of "Downton Abbey," I would not disagree because The Secret Rooms tells much of aristocratic life in Britain before and during the First World War. But this book is more than an historical accounting of a great family; it has much to share of a psychological nature as Bailey exposes secrets the family wanted to remain hidden. (The ninth duke was so successful that the current duke had no clue of what the author discovered.)
It's not my place to divulge what those secrets were, but in the unveiling of the one involving the first year of the war, I felt the author went off the rails a bit. Once the reader knows what was hidden, why, and who was responsible, Bailey goes into minute detail over each fact that she discovered and how it was discovered. Instead of making me feel outrage and sorrow at what was done, I soon became impatient and my enthusiasm for the book as a whole began to wane from its original high. Two-thirds of The Secret Rooms is fascinating,and I'm glad I read it, but that final third does drag a bit.
It's not my place to divulge what those secrets were, but in the unveiling of the one involving the first year of the war, I felt the author went off the rails a bit. Once the reader knows what was hidden, why, and who was responsible, Bailey goes into minute detail over each fact that she discovered and how it was discovered. Instead of making me feel outrage and sorrow at what was done, I soon became impatient and my enthusiasm for the book as a whole began to wane from its original high. Two-thirds of The Secret Rooms is fascinating,and I'm glad I read it, but that final third does drag a bit.
Maura (maura853) -
Well-researched and well-written, but Bailey (and, more likely, her publisher) have tried a little too hard to ratchet up the suspense and "shock, horror" aspects. The title is, honestly, very misleading. The "secret" rooms weren't THAT secret, and you can make up your own mind whether there's any haunting. And did EVERY chapter have to end with a lame cliffhanger? Cheap shock tactics undermined what was a very sad and interesting story that needed no added dramatics. It would convince anyone that, however bad things seem today, they could have been far, far worse for our ancestors of only a couple of generations ago.
Enjoyable and well-written, especially if you're a fan of Downton Abbey, or interested in late-Victorian/early 20th Century history, or World War I, or all of the above.
Enjoyable and well-written, especially if you're a fan of Downton Abbey, or interested in late-Victorian/early 20th Century history, or World War I, or all of the above.
Dharshini Y. (astralcars) reviewed The Secret Rooms: A True Story of a Haunted Castle, a Plotting Duchess, and a Family Secret on
No matter how much I tried, I just could not get through this book.
