Helpful Score: 4
If anyone has seen the movie "The Magdalene Sisters", this book is a milder version of it. It kept my interest but I felt the the main character was not treated as harshly as the stories I've heard about the Magdalene Asylums.
Helpful Score: 4
Heartrbreaking, but realistic portrait of both the humanity of and the stigma attached to unmarried mothers just 50 years ago.
Helpful Score: 2
I enjoyed this story about a young Irish-Catholic girl who became pregnant "out of wedlock"--(sounds like a disease, doesn't it?). She was 'graciously' accepted to a home for unwed mothers run by an order of nuns. They agreed to provide a good, clean, place to work (at the laundry service run by the nuns) and live until her baby was born, and then would find a loving Catholic home to adopt the baby. Things were rough in the 50's and unwed women were considered 'wild and wanton, women who had no morals or upbringing'. The were forced to live a hard, austere, life if the "father" chose not to marry her. The mother then gave the baby up for adoption and went back to her home as if nothing had happened. These poor women became so down-trodden that many of them just stayed at the laundry for the rest of thier lives. This is a wonderfully written accoun of that era. It had a fast start and kept up the pace right until the surprise ending. The characters are well-developed and you feel as if you really did know them.
Helpful Score: 1
Extremely extremely sad
I have seen this book on Amazon several times while looking for memoirs about women who have lived inside the Magdalen laundry facilities. I never bought this one becuase I thought it might not touch on my emotions as much as a true story would. Well, I ended up finding this at my local Goodwill so I decided I would go ahead and read it. I'm really glad I did! I stayed up way past my normal bedtime becuase I just couldn't bring myself to put this book down!
The Magdalen is about Esther a country girl from a small fishing community in Ireland in the late 1940's to early 1950's. When tragedy strikes Esther's family leaving Esther and her mother at odds with eachother it makes Esthers situation even more difficult. Esther has a secret and it's not one taken lightly in the Ireland run by the church. She can't hide this secret for long becuase soon it will be showing itself to the world. When Esthers mother finally confronts her Esther is relieved to finally be able to confide in her family, but the reliefe is short lived as tension and anger fill the families small seaside cottage to the brim.
Being a religously devout woman Esther's mother turns to their parish priest to help them find a solution to Esther's problem. Reluctantly Esther agrees to the priest's suggestion that she go stay in a Magdalen laundry facility run by the nuns. It might seem like the right solution to Esther's family, but for Esther it's down right heartbreaking.
Although I really enjoyed this book a lot I only gave it four stars becuase the begining is a bit slow.
The Magdalen is about Esther a country girl from a small fishing community in Ireland in the late 1940's to early 1950's. When tragedy strikes Esther's family leaving Esther and her mother at odds with eachother it makes Esthers situation even more difficult. Esther has a secret and it's not one taken lightly in the Ireland run by the church. She can't hide this secret for long becuase soon it will be showing itself to the world. When Esthers mother finally confronts her Esther is relieved to finally be able to confide in her family, but the reliefe is short lived as tension and anger fill the families small seaside cottage to the brim.
Being a religously devout woman Esther's mother turns to their parish priest to help them find a solution to Esther's problem. Reluctantly Esther agrees to the priest's suggestion that she go stay in a Magdalen laundry facility run by the nuns. It might seem like the right solution to Esther's family, but for Esther it's down right heartbreaking.
Although I really enjoyed this book a lot I only gave it four stars becuase the begining is a bit slow.
This is a great book.
From back cover Esther Doyle is a true child of Connemara. She is a simple girl with a true heart, and the wild and tangled land of the West sings in her bones. But when Esther is betrayed by her lover and left unmarried and pregnant, the sea and sky are both lost to her... Order to find out what happpens.
From back cover Esther Doyle is a true child of Connemara. She is a simple girl with a true heart, and the wild and tangled land of the West sings in her bones. But when Esther is betrayed by her lover and left unmarried and pregnant, the sea and sky are both lost to her... Order to find out what happpens.
This one really didn't live up to the hype. It's a pretty straightforward tale about a naive young girl from County Connemara who loves well but not wisely, and is introduced to harsh reality when she becomes pregnant and the child's father refuses to marry her, having better prospects at hand.
As was not unusual in Ireland in the 1950s, Esther's only practical choice is to enter a Catholic convent specializing in the housing of "wayward girls and fallen women" to await the birth of her child, which she must agree to place in the attached orphanage and make available for adoption. During her confinement, she works in the convent's commercial laundry and undergoes various hardships both physical and emotional.
At the end, she gives birth, realizes she loves her baby, has second thoughts about releasing it for adoption, is told she has no choice in the matter, and chooses to stay in Dublin afterwards rather than returning to the family which scorned her. She is sure she can survive and still holds the dream of someday being united with her lost child.
And while there's nothing really wrong with the book, there's nothing particularly significant about it, either. The characters are internally consistent; Esther's actions in the throes of first love are believable; the reader can tell from a mile away where the boyfriend's true intentions lie; the nuns are suitably unsympathetic to their charges; and the girls with whom Esther shares her confinement fall neatly into various categories.
Readers looking for an overview of the whole Magdalene Laundry system would probably be better off with nonfiction studies. Those looking for an engrossing fictional tale of one of its graduates will need to keep searching.
As was not unusual in Ireland in the 1950s, Esther's only practical choice is to enter a Catholic convent specializing in the housing of "wayward girls and fallen women" to await the birth of her child, which she must agree to place in the attached orphanage and make available for adoption. During her confinement, she works in the convent's commercial laundry and undergoes various hardships both physical and emotional.
At the end, she gives birth, realizes she loves her baby, has second thoughts about releasing it for adoption, is told she has no choice in the matter, and chooses to stay in Dublin afterwards rather than returning to the family which scorned her. She is sure she can survive and still holds the dream of someday being united with her lost child.
And while there's nothing really wrong with the book, there's nothing particularly significant about it, either. The characters are internally consistent; Esther's actions in the throes of first love are believable; the reader can tell from a mile away where the boyfriend's true intentions lie; the nuns are suitably unsympathetic to their charges; and the girls with whom Esther shares her confinement fall neatly into various categories.
Readers looking for an overview of the whole Magdalene Laundry system would probably be better off with nonfiction studies. Those looking for an engrossing fictional tale of one of its graduates will need to keep searching.
interestng story about young Irish girl lsent to work at the nunnertys laundry house when she has an unwanted pregnancy.
