Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of The Coldest Girl in Coldtown

The Coldest Girl in Coldtown
The Coldest Girl in Coldtown
Author: Holly Black
ISBN-13: 9780316213103
ISBN-10: 0316213101
Publication Date: 9/17/2013
Pages: 432
Rating:
  • Currently 4/5 Stars.
 30

4 stars, based on 30 ratings
Publisher: Little, Brown Books for Young Readers
Book Type: Hardcover
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

3 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

skywriter319 avatar reviewed The Coldest Girl in Coldtown on + 784 more book reviews
I'm not the type of reader to instantly dismiss all vampire stories out of vampire fatigue; as long as it's written well, I can enjoy it. And THE COLDEST GIRL IN COLDTOWN is written *well*. It brings me back to Holly Black's Tithe era, with its grungy urban landscapes full of disaffected, multiply pierced, dyed-haired teenage characters who are simultaneously cooler and yet more vulnerable than you'll ever be. Black's narrative swirls between settings and time periods and points of view in a style that I imagine is like what being on raver drugs must feel like. Slightly disorienting, swirls of more-than-they-seem interactions and side-goings-on piquing the corners of your vision, disorienting your understanding of reality so slyly, so insidiously, that when you pause to take a breather from reading this story, you blink and for more than a second think that Black's world could very well exist, unobserved, in your own. Gavriel, the male vampire love interest, even gets me hot and bothered just like the icy-hot Roiben (Rath Roiben Rye, Rath Roiben Rye) of Tithe did.

Verdict? If you love your vampire tales slightly darker and hipper and more insane, get up this alley. If, like me, you spent your formative years gorging on Holly Black's classic urban fantasy YAs, get at this one. If you like your paranormals more romance-y and plot-driven, then this will probably not be your cup of tea.
skywriter319 avatar reviewed The Coldest Girl in Coldtown on + 784 more book reviews
I'm not the type of reader to instantly dismiss all vampire stories out of vampire fatigue; as long as it's written well, I can enjoy it. And THE COLDEST GIRL IN COLDTOWN is written *well*. It brings me back to Holly Black's Tithe era, with its grungy urban landscapes full of disaffected, multiply pierced, dyed-haired teenage characters who are simultaneously cooler and yet more vulnerable than you'll ever be. Black's narrative swirls between settings and time periods and points of view in a style that I imagine is like what being on raver drugs must feel like. Slightly disorienting, swirls of more-than-they-seem interactions and side-goings-on piquing the corners of your vision, disorienting your understanding of reality so slyly, so insidiously, that when you pause to take a breather from reading this story, you blink and for more than a second think that Black's world could very well exist, unobserved, in your own. Gavriel, the male vampire love interest, even gets me hot and bothered just like the icy-hot Roiben (Rath Roiben Rye, Rath Roiben Rye) of Tithe did.

Verdict? If you love your vampire tales slightly darker and hipper and more insane, get up this alley. If, like me, you spent your formative years gorging on Holly Black's classic urban fantasy YAs, get at this one. If you like your paranormals more romance-y and plot-driven, then this will probably not be your cup of tea.
ophelia99 avatar reviewed The Coldest Girl in Coldtown on + 2527 more book reviews
I got a copy of this book to review through NetGalley(dot)com. I have really enjoyed Holly Blacks Spiderwick Chronicles and Modern Faerie Tale series so I was looking forward to her next young adult series. This was a very good young adult book thats part dystopia/part vampire story.

In a world where vampirism is a highly contagious virus, vampires are put in Coldtowns to protect the rest of humanity from them. This book follows a girl named Tana who wakes up at a party and finds all of her friends slaughtered. She finds her boyfriend infected (going Cold) and doesn't know if she herself is infected or not. She also finds a somewhat crazed and strangely kind vampire chained up in the room with her boyfriend. This all leads Tana to take a desperate trip to the closest Coldtown and their she finds that Coldtowns aren't anything like publicity would lead normal humans to believe.

You can't help but compare this book a bit to Julie Kagawa's Blood of Eden series. Humanity is a lot better off in this book, this book portrays a world that looks like it is on the way to becoming a world like the one portrayed in the Blood of Eden series. Vampires are not the good guys in this book, they are fairly vicious. Although some of them try to fit in with human society.

The situation in the Coldtowns definitely has a dystopian vibe to it. Everyone on the outside thinks that life in Coldtown is all parties and glitter, but once Tana gets in there she finds out its not like that at all.

The description throughout this book is fantastic, the scenes really come alive in all their gothic dreadfulness. There is some seriously wonderful description here and that made this a darkly lyrical read.

Tana is easy to engage with as a character; she is a good girl and tries to do what's right but is constantly fighting with a daring and darkness that she finds alluring. She is a bit of a wild child, but strangely pragmatic as well.

Gavriel is the strangely insane, yet kind, vampire that tries to befriend Tana. He was a wonderful character full of vampiric creepiness as well as a strange humanity. He has some seriously interesting secrets and I really enjoyed reading about him.

The world is a bleak one without much hope and Tana is forced to find a way to survive in it. There are some very violent and gory scenes in here as well; as I said it is similar in tone to Kagawas Blood of Eden series...just a little less bleak.

They plot was a bit predictable. I pretty much figured out Gavriels secret right when we meet him. That being said there are still a couple good twists and turns. The book was very engaging and hard to put down.

Overall I enjoyed the story, it was a good one. The story is nicely wrapped up, although there could be another book after this one because there are some loose ends. The world is an interesting one, the description throughout is spectacular, and the characters are engaging. I would recommend to those who enjoy dystopian vampire type stories. I would especially recommend to those who have enjoyed Kagawas Blood of Eden series since the subject matter and tone are similar.