Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of A Circle of Souls

A Circle of Souls
A Circle of Souls
Author: Preetham Grandhi
ISBN-13: 9781599552354
ISBN-10: 1599552353
Publication Date: 6/15/2009
Pages: 352
Edition: 1
Rating:
  • Currently 3.6/5 Stars.
 7

3.6 stars, based on 7 ratings
Publisher: Cedar Fort
Book Type: Paperback
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

7 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

donkeycheese avatar reviewed A Circle of Souls on + 1255 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
In the small town of Newbury, Connecticut a young girl named Janet is found brutally murdered. Since her backpack was found on a Senators land and he is about to campaign, they call in one of the best FBI profilers to take the case.

Leia Bines in an expert in cases involving children, but the clues arent there to help her in this particular case. Shell take any lead she can find and run with it, and hope she finds the killer before he strikes again.

Naya Hastings is a young girl whose dreams are endangering her life. She enacts them as she dreams, and in one particular case, she almost fell over the balcony. Her parents take her to child psychologist Dr. Peter Gram. During the course of a few days, observing and testing Naya, he comes to the conclusion that something out of the ordinary is happening with Naya.

She spends her days drawing pictures of her dreams, and she explains to Peter that she has been talking with Janet and that he would know what to do. Peter is stunned since there is no way Naya could know about the young girl who was murdered. He borrows Nayas drawings and shows them to Leia Bines in case they help; even if she may think him crazy. What transpires is a roller coaster of emotion that cultivates into the final shocking conclusion.

A Circle of Souls is very hard to put down. I read it in one sitting! A psychological thriller of magnificent proportions. Wonderful characters, a well thought out plot, and descriptive just enough to make you want take this wonderful thrilling ride with him. His background in psychology is obvious and he uses that to his advantage is making A Circle of Souls comfortable to the reader. One of the best books Ive read this year hands down!
confuzzledbooks avatar reviewed A Circle of Souls on + 486 more book reviews
Young Janet says goodbye to a school mate one day and disappears the next; FBI agent Leia Bines has been given the case. Another little girl, named Naya, starts sleepwalking and dreaming about a girl named Janet, and Naya's doctor begins to see starling resemblances in Naya's drawings to the case of the girl.

Delving a little into the spirituality and thriller genres, A Circle of Souls is an eye-catching read with great flow. I read a couple books at a time, and I was always eager to get back to this one. With short chapters there is still so much going on, and I enjoyed the characters like Naya (a happy child who is good at art) and the doctor (caring thoughtful and open minded).
readermuse avatar reviewed A Circle of Souls on + 96 more book reviews
A Circle of Souls by Preetham Grandi is a murder mystery thriller with a slight paranormal twist. Amazon's quick summation is as follows:"The sleepy town of Newbury, Connecticut, is shocked when a little girl is found brutally murdered. With the murderer on the loose, the police desperately look for any clues to lead to his identy. Meanwhile, a psychiatrist in a nearby hospital is also in a desperate search to find the cause of seven-year-old Naya Hastings s devastating nightmares. Afraid that she might hurt herself in the midst of a torturous episode, Naya's parents have turned to the bright young doctor as their only hope. When these two situations converge, they set off an alarming chain of events. In this stunning psychological thriller, innocence gives way to evil, and trust lies forgotten in a web of deceit, fear, and murder."

I got this book from the author as an ARC. It is my first and I was very intrigued to read it. I had worked in a hospital for children with psychological problems and wanted to see his take on it. The author didn't disappoint and was very accurate in his description in that area. The story on the whole draws you into the mystery even though you are a "witness" to the initial crime which starts the story. Within the book, you are reading several points of view, but because of the layout of the chapters, you never get lost. The paranormal aspect begins with Naya's dreams and the main character, Peter, who is determined to figure out exactly what those dreams mean.

My main complaints with the book are perhaps minor and really doesn't take away from the story as a whole. First, he does not cuss. Now this isn't anything bad, but it is an adult novel and kids in a situation in a locked-down facility do and will cuss. If told from Naya's perspective, it wouldn't have bothered me, but it continued with Peter and the others as well. I wondered if the author had a problem with cussing.

Another problem I had was with the philosophy of fatalism. It was explained too simplistically. Even within the concept of fatalism there is an aspect of free will. No matter how contradictory that sounds, the aspect is there. Usually it is explained not as an something that you will do without choice, but if you go against fatalism, your life will not be as fulfilling and happy as it would have been otherwise.

I also felt the ending was a bit abrupt. I will not say more as it could ruin the ending, but I would have like a bit more of it drawn out. Not by much, but a little. Even with this criticism I will say the ending was interesting and sets things up for a possible second book. One that should also prove to be a good read.

On the whole, however, I would say that this book is good. It holds you interest well and keeps you trying to figure out exactly how and why until those mysteries are revealed. One that gets the wheels turning in your head and satisfies you with a ending that makes you want more.
emeraldfire avatar reviewed A Circle of Souls on
When the quiet town of Newbury, Connecticut, is rocked by the brutal murder of ten-year-old Janet Troy, the FBI send in their best agent, Leia Bines - an expert in cases involving children - to solve the case. Already reeling from the result of her previous case, Leia reluctantly agrees to take the case.

Meanwhile, child psychiatrist Dr. Peter Gram, is dealing with a new patient. Seven-year-old Naya Hastings has been brought to him suffering from horrific nightmares. The only clues to her nightly terrors are the drawings that she does in the morning. As Naya's drawings become more violent, Peter becomes increasingly more worried for Naya.

As the townspeople struggle to come to terms with Janet's murder and Agent Bines struggles to find a killer, Naya's drawings hold all the clues in a tangled case of lies, deceit and serial murder. It falls to Leia and Peter to uncover these clues before time runs out.

I would definitely recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a touch of the supernatural about their mysteries. I give this book an A+!
reviewed A Circle of Souls on + 11 more book reviews
A Circle of Souls, by Preetham Grandhi, is a paranormal thriller that is entertaining all the way. A little girl is murdered, and another little girl seems to have the answers to the murder in her nightmares. Child psychiatrist Dr. Peter Gram gets involved in putting the puzzle pieces together.

The thing that attracted me most to this book, outside of the cover, was the authors background. Born and raised in the city of Bangalore, India, his determination led to a new life in the US, where he found himself working with children in inner Bronx who had childhoods even more complex than his own.

This book is outside my normal genre, and I was uncomfortable with the concept of Seekers and Seeked Ones, reincarnation and fortune-telling, though they were certainly thought-provoking. And the gruesome beginnings were a bit of a turnoff for me, though they were compensated by a spirit of hope that pervaded the book.

Reservations aside, I found this to be an easy-reading page-turner that kept me intrigued from beginning to end. I kept feeling compelled to read on.

It was obvious that the author wrote in his field of expertise, child psychiatry, and I appreciated the insights into that field. The characters were well-developed through alternating third-person chapters, with likable but human heroes and sinister but human villains.

An amazing debut novel.
Jennmarie68 avatar reviewed A Circle of Souls on + 217 more book reviews
I won this book in a giveaway in which the author asked the winner to provide a review.

This was a really gripping story. I was drawn in right from the beginning. The story is so fast paced that it kept my interest and I finished it in almost one setting. Even the "down-times" in the story were interesting. The author's background (culturally and educationally) lent themselves really well to this book. Nothing that happened in the story seemed far fetched, as tends to happen in murder mysteries sometimes. I could tell that the author knew the intricacies of the story he was telling. I didn't get the feeling that he was just making stuff up to keep the story more interesting.

The characters in this one were so well developed. I fell in love with Naya. She was such a sweet little girl. As soon as she was brought into the story I liked her. The characters were so well developed that I could picture them and was able to "predict" their reactions. Not that the story was predictable, but similar to how when you've known someone for a while you can kind of guess what they might say or do.

The story itself was very well written. The dialog was real. The story was plausible. And it was really a mystery. I thought I had it figured out a few times. And even despite the possible endings my brain was coming up with I didn't expect it to turn out the way it did! The book was able to create a mystery without going into overly gory detail. It wasn't a gratuitous use of gore, it was done with taste.

I have to say that this is one of the best books I've ever read. It really was a quick read, at almost 350 pages it only took me 3 settings to finish it. It was just so captivating and fast paced that I didn't want to put it down.
rxtheresa avatar reviewed A Circle of Souls on + 27 more book reviews
OK so I'm in the medical profession, I work in a psychiatric hospital, I grew up in Ct, I've always been interested in Indian culture and the paranormal, in other words, this book was right up my alley. I didn't read about the author before I started the book but the accuracy of the hospital practices and treatment lead me to read about him. Of course he is a doctor, a psychiatrist. This was a thrilling, fast read. I did figure out who the perp was before it was revealed but it in no way took away from the story. The only thing disturbing to me was some of the practices of the murderer. As expected from a psychiatrist he gave the criminal's background and why he did what he did. I highly recommend it.