Maura (maura853) - , reviewed on 12/17/2018 + 542 more book reviews

A little gem. I had heard so much about this book, at various times and from various people, that I was certain that I was heading for a disappointment. How could anything, not much more than a novella, be that good? Trust me, it is that good. Carr's skill at weaving together time, place, and character, symbolism and imagery, dialogue and authorial voice, in a perfect little whole, is nothing short of breathtaking. Any random page could serve as a masterclass in writing that captures a time, a voice and a heartbreaking set of circumstances.

Whew. I should confess that Carr is playing to some of my favorite topics, as if he had a little checklist next to him as he wrote. Village in northern England? Check. Village church, full of fascinating tombs and memorials, and a bit of a mystery. Check. He had me at "hidden medieval mural." But the way Carr captures the bittersweet recollection of a fleeting episode in life is both very specific (Tom Birkin is a physically and mentally wounded veteran of the World War I trenches, trying to decide whether the peace-time life he has returned to was worth the effort of surviving) and universal (who can't point to some episode in our lives when a different sort of life seems just within grasp - and would we have been happier if we had reached out and taken it?)

Highly recommended.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details