Helpful Score: 1
I read Crow Lake a few years back and had really enjoyed it; decided to see if I'd like this one as much. I don't know what it is exactly about her writing but I thoroughly loved it, the way the characters were each so strongly portrayed and believable. I read a lot and Mary Lawson just has something many authors don't--now if I only I could put my finger on what it was. Depth?
Helpful Score: 1
The story is told in alternating chapters. Two distinct stories in their own right, running together and intersecting. The story of Arthur Dunn and his brother Jake growing up in the 1930's and Ian Christopherson's story of coming to age in a small northern town in the 50's. Ian and Arthur are the tie that bind the stories together. Slowly and gently taking us through the lives of these two men and building to the inescapable explosion between brothers.
I like stories about family struggles, we all have them don't we? I love looking at the dynamic of relationships. This book hit home for me in two ways, Arthur has a 'co-dependent' relationship with his mother. He felt responsible for her happiness. Somewhere along the lines in their lives she sent that message to him. I had the same dynamic in my relationship with my mom. So I could identify with Arthur. There was Jake the brother whom the mom treated with kid gloves, I have a handicap brother. Same dynamic. With Ian one of his parents abandons the family and he has to learn to come to terms with that. My dad left us when I was a teenager.
The setting is really far north in Ontario Canada, small town life, farm life. Ms. Lawson puts you right there in that bitter cold winter. Pulls at your heartstrings when a horse gets sick in the middle of a blizzard, they can't get to the vet. Ian has a Native Indian best friend from the reservation and we see the tensions between the Indians and the white man.Throw in World War II and the hardships and the terrible loss.
I loved Arthur and as much as you want to dislike Jake you have to wonder why? Why does he do the things he does? The dynamics between the brothers really is the crux of the story and it is a very well told one. I'm very glad she decided to tell this story from Arthur's point of view instead of Jake's. Their dad was a silent man and even though he doesn't say much, I think his relationship with each of the boys speaks volumes. I can't recommend this enough if you like family dramas!
I like stories about family struggles, we all have them don't we? I love looking at the dynamic of relationships. This book hit home for me in two ways, Arthur has a 'co-dependent' relationship with his mother. He felt responsible for her happiness. Somewhere along the lines in their lives she sent that message to him. I had the same dynamic in my relationship with my mom. So I could identify with Arthur. There was Jake the brother whom the mom treated with kid gloves, I have a handicap brother. Same dynamic. With Ian one of his parents abandons the family and he has to learn to come to terms with that. My dad left us when I was a teenager.
The setting is really far north in Ontario Canada, small town life, farm life. Ms. Lawson puts you right there in that bitter cold winter. Pulls at your heartstrings when a horse gets sick in the middle of a blizzard, they can't get to the vet. Ian has a Native Indian best friend from the reservation and we see the tensions between the Indians and the white man.Throw in World War II and the hardships and the terrible loss.
I loved Arthur and as much as you want to dislike Jake you have to wonder why? Why does he do the things he does? The dynamics between the brothers really is the crux of the story and it is a very well told one. I'm very glad she decided to tell this story from Arthur's point of view instead of Jake's. Their dad was a silent man and even though he doesn't say much, I think his relationship with each of the boys speaks volumes. I can't recommend this enough if you like family dramas!
Helpful Score: 1
I enjoyed this book. It is very well written and the story is interesting. I enjoyed Mary Lawson's first book - Crow Lake - much more. Crow Lake is one of my favorite books of all time.
